Print Print Comment Comment Add to Favorites
Log in to save to My Yoga Journal!
Add to Favorites
Bookmark Bookmark

How to Avoid Misusing Anatomical Language

When you misuse anatomical terminology, you run the risk of confusing your students and calling your credibility into question. Here's how to avoid common mistakes.

By Julie Gudmestad

tree_class

It's with a mixture of amazement, amusement, and sometimes sadness that I listen to yoga teachers and students discuss anatomy in the context of asana practice. Sometimes I'm amazed and impressed by a teacher's understanding of anatomy and movement, and by his or her ability to describe it in clear and engaging terms that highlight the students' experience in the pose. Sometimes an anatomical description is enough off course to make a laugh-out-loud image. And sometimes it's just plain sad that we, as teachers, are squandering a learning opportunity for our students by disseminating erroneous information, when we could be helping them deepen their understanding of not only the yoga poses but also their own bodies.

Know the Difference Between Injury and Anatomy

Often when teachers make an anatomy mistake while describing a pose in class, they're simply repeating a common misunderstanding. Some of my favorites include body-part names that have become synonymous with injuries. These include using "rotator cuff," which is a group of four muscles that help move and stabilize the ball in the socket of the shoulder joint, to mean a rotator cuff tear. Or "TMJ," which is the temporomandibular (jaw) joint, to mean a TMJ problem or injury. So I may have someone approach me to report that "I have TMJ" or "I have rotator cuff," and I have to stifle the temptation to say, "Oh really? I have two of them."

Describe Movement Effectively

Other common mistakes I hear teachers make involve the incorrect use of terms to describe movement. There is actually a fairly simple, straightforward system that anatomists and kinesiologists use to describe human movement and joint positions. However, most people need to invest some time and practice in order to learn it and use the descriptive words correctly. In yoga teaching, the word "extension" seems to cause the most problems, as teachers want to use the word to describe opening, lengthening, and uncompressing a body part. In anatomy, the word describes precise movements and positions. For example, shoulder extension occurs when the arms reach back behind you, as in Sarvangasana (Shoulderstand): the shoulders are flexed when the arms stretch up overhead. Hip extension occurs when the thigh is in line with the torso, as opposed to the thigh angling forward, as happens when we sit in chairs. In a spinal extension the spine arches, as in a backbend. So if you ask me (or other medical professionals) to extend my spine while standing in Tadasana (Mountain Pose), I will lean backward into a backbend, risking compression in my lower back, which is probably the opposite of the intended uncompressing of the spine.

Be Clear

Another common category of confusion for students is the location of frequently referenced body parts, including muscles, joints, and bones. In general, deeper structures such as the psoas and piriformis muscles and the kidneys tend to be the most mysterious, but students can even be stumped by more superficial structures like the sacroiliac joints, the scapula, and the trapezius muscle. As I mentioned in my last column, "Anatomy Lesson,"it's always a good idea to have your students find the structures in their own bodies before you give instructions about how to position or move them. Otherwise your students may try hard to comply with your instructions but really have no idea what you're talking about.

Make Sure It's Anatomically Possible

Probably my biggest concern has to do with teachers asking students to perform actions that a muscle can't do, or can't do in that position. To me, that sets up a disconnect between the verbal, cerebral understanding of the action/position and what is actually happening in the body—in effect, the student learns that they can't trust their own experience. For example, I've heard a teacher ask students to "Relax your neck" in sideways standing poses such as Utthita Trikonasana (Extended Triangle Pose) and Utthita Parsvakonasana (Extended Side Angle Pose). In those poses, practiced to the right, the left neck muscles are actually contracting to hold up the weight of the head against the pull of gravity. If the neck muscles relaxed, the head would hang down. While we do want a long neck (maximum distance between the ears and shoulder blades on both sides), the neck muscles are not truly relaxing. Other interesting but, sadly, not physically possible instructions I've heard are: Move the psoas to the right or left; relax your abdominals (but don't allow the lower back to over arch away from the floor) in Urdhva Prasarita Padasana (Leg Lifts); and release and relax your serratus anterior muscles as you stretch your arms overhead. One of the most unfortunate instructions involves asking tight students, whose fingers don't touch the floor as they hang down, to relax their hamstrings in Uttanasana (Standing Forward Bend). With no support from the arms, the hamstrings are actually contracting to support the torso and prevent falling to the floor. For these students, who desperately need to learn to relax and lengthen their hams, they are learning from their teacher's words that "stretching" is actually contracting.

Ideally, as yoga teachers, we can use language to help our students deepen the connection between body and mind, ears and muscles, as teachers and students alike grow toward wholeness. Sometimes, that growth requires a bit of study by teachers to improve the clarity and accuracy of our instructions.

Julie Gudmestad is a certified Iyengar Yoga teacher and licensed physical therapist who runs a combined yoga studio and physical therapy practice in Portland, Oregon. She enjoys integrating her Western medical knowledge with the healing powers of yoga to help make the wisdom of yoga accessible to all.
Print Print Comment Comment Add to Favorites
Log in to save to My Yoga Journal!
Add to Favorites
Bookmark Bookmark
Full Name
Address 1
Address 2
City:
State:
Zip Code:
Email (req):

Reader Comments

Metajag

I agree with the notion of being as precise and accurate with anatomical language as possible, and if as a teacher you don’t know, refrain from saying. That said, it’s not easy to always articulate accurately, and some of these insights almost sound like some rather smug one-upmanship. Case in point: “Hip extension occurs when the thigh is in line with the torso, as opposed to the thigh angling forward.” What does “in line with” mean? Out to the side? My thigh is in line with my torso when it’s angling forward, no? Or straight down, when I’m standing, right? What exactly does “angling forward” mean, in fact? It’s not easy to get it right, and that should be acknowledged. Language is fluid, and anatomy is complex, and we need to have compassion. And THAT said, I’m returning to my anatomy books post haste! Sheesh! This is HARD!

Kristin

A great article that many yoga teachers should read. I think many teachers unfortunately feel like they have to be anatomy experts as soon as they jump out of teacher training (or without much further study), because of the increase in alignment-based practices. It's unfortunate that, in order to sound knowledgeable, they feel the need to use terms that they might not be 100% comfortable using, or familiar with, which just leads to confusion at best, and misinformation at worst.
As a teacher myself, and a bit of an "anatomy nerd" (but not an expert), I try and stick to clear terminology that is accessible to all my students, and language that I am comfortable with, and know what it means.
In other words, teachers, take a step back, breathe, and don't be afraid to use simpler language that both you and your students understand, as well as the old, "I'm not sure, but I'll look it up for you."
There is a huge demand for us to be both yoga teachers and medical/anatomical experts, and I would venture to say, the vast majority of us are just yoga teachers, with better than average knowledge of anatomy (and perhaps physiology). I can totally understand the pressure to be more knowledgeable in anatomy, biomechanics, etc., though! At the same time, don't feel inadequate if you're "just" a yoga teacher!

Shelly

Thanks for writing this! I really appreciate these observations. I often have a hard time comprehending what is being asked of me and translating it to my body. Sometimes teachers say, "move the pubic bone toward the coccyx" - is this possible?

See All Comments »      Add a Comment »

Your Name:

Comment:

Stay Connected with Us!

Yoga Journal Live events
sd14 San Diego
Sheraton San Diego
July 10-14, 2014
Register
2014 new york live New York
Hilton New York
April 24-28, 2014
Register

More Events

Join Yoga Journal's Benefits Plus
Liability insurance and benefits to support
teachers and studios.
Learn More
Get 2 FREE Trial Issues and 4 FREE GIFTS
Your subscription includes
Yoga for Neck & Shoulders • Yoga Remedies
Yoga for Headaches • Calm, Cool, Collected
YES! Please send me my FREE trial issues of Yoga Journal
and my 4 FREE downloadable Yoga Booklets.
Full Name:
City:
Address 1:
Zip Code:
State:
Address 2:
Email (required):
Free trial offer valid for US subscribers only. Canadian subscriptions | International subscriptions