Become a Member

Get access to more than 30 brands, premium video, exclusive content, events, mapping, and more.

Already have an account? Sign In

Become a Member

Get access to more than 30 brands, premium video, exclusive content, events, mapping, and more.

Already have an account? Sign In



Exercise and Sacrifice

Get full access to Outside Learn, our online education hub featuring in-depth yoga, fitness, & nutrition courses, when you sign up for Outside+.

Last month, we explained why it’s necessary to distinguish between Yin and Yang tissues. Yang tissues should be exercised in a Yang way and Yin tissues should be exercised in a Yin way. Muscles are Yang, while bones and connective tissue are Yin. Yang muscles should be exercised with rhythm and repetition. Connective tissue or bone should be exercised with long periods of stasis or stillness. The rhythmic contraction and relaxation of weight lifting is the proper way to train our muscles. The long, sustained pressure of braces on our teeth is the proper way to train our connective tissue and thereby change our body’s alignment.

Exercising Yang tissue in a Yin way could be damaging–and vice versa. Doing deep squats at the gym and holding each one for a long time could be disastrous for the spine and knees. Rhythmically wiggling our teeth back and forth could be disastrous for our gums.

Exercise should be modified according to the tissue we wish to affect, but just what is exercise? How does it work? This is the subject of today’s article.

Theory of Exercise

The fundamental theory of exercise is that we must stress a tissue to make it stronger. We lift weights at the gym to increase our muscle strength. Ironically, we are weaker after our training then when we started. After we stress our muscles during training, they are left exhausted. Indeed, it is a measure of pride for a body builder to brag how he didn’t have the strength to tie his shoes after a “good” session.

If the goal of weight training is to get stronger, than why do we try so hard to exhaust and weaken the muscles? The answer is that we hope that once we have recovered, our muscles will be stronger. Our muscles are improved by our efforts. In fact, straining and exhausting our muscles results in their being not just repaired but improved by growing more nerves, blood vessels and proteins. When we stop to think of it, this is remarkable! How does this happen?

The bottom line is nobody knows.

The ancient Yogis recognized this enigmatic ability of life to modify itself and attributed it to a life force they called “prana.” The Taoists called this life force “chi.” It is this life force that distinguishes the living from the nonliving. If we were to routinely stretch and twist a piece of rope, it would not “recover and grow stronger.” The rope would simply weaken, fray and eventually break.

The ability to grow and adapt to stress defines living things. Rocks and sticks don’t adapt to stresses, they just crumble under them.

Theory of Sacrifice

In ancient scriptures, the Theory of Exercise was subsumed by a larger Theory of Sacrifice. The Theory of Sacrifice is that we must give up some of what we have if we are going to gain more of it in return. The Theory of Sacrifice included not just the physical realm but all realms of human endeavor, including the political and spiritual. Indian scriptures are replete with stories of sacrifices that lasted days and were enormously expensive. Sacrifices were performed to insure harvest, to bring prosperity to a kingdom, and to ward off plague.

Although not so explicit, the Theory of Sacrifice is still with us. In exercise, we sacrifice our strength in order to gain greater strength. In investment, we risk our money in order to gain more money. In vaccination, we sicken the body with a weakened form of disease in order to increase its resistance.

Each time we lift a weight we are making a sacrifice. These acts of sacrifice make us weaker, not stronger. It is our hope that our sacrifice will be rewarded by increased strength. Do we know exactly how this happens? No. Do we have any control over how strong we will get? No. Do we have any control over how long it will take? No. All of these things are out of our control. All we can control is the sacrifice we are willing to make. In the Bhagavad Gita II:47, Krishna says to Arjuna: “Man has it in his power to sacrifice but the fruits of his sacrifice are not in his power.”

Stress: Too Much or Too Little?

All living tissues adapt to the stresses put upon them. When an astronaut spends weeks in a weightless environment, she loses 15-20 percent of her bone mass. This is because her bones are not stressed by weight bearing exercise, so her bones adapt by releasing calcium and altering their structure. If we do not stress our bones, they will atrophy. If we do not stress our muscles through work and exercise, they will atrophy. The tissues in our bodies need to be stressed in order to be strong. This is a law of life. Use it or lose it.

Of course, it is possible to overstress the tissues of our bodies. We can wear down our strength by overexerting and not allowing adequate recovery time. We can overstress our bones and joints by straining against too much weight. We can consume too much salt and raise our blood pressure. We can consume too little salt and lose our electrolyte balance. Too little stress causes our tissues to atrophy and too much stress breaks them down. This is the play of Yin and Yang. Proper health is between these two extremes.

Connective Tissue

We now understand that the Theory of Sacrifice or Theory of Exercise asserts that the proper health of our tissues is created by alternately stressing them and then allowing sufficient time to recover. This theory is readily accepted as regards aerobic and strength conditioning. In fact, it is almost too obvious to bother elaborating. So why spend nearly a thousand words examining it? Because yoga extends this theory beyond muscle and bone and systematically applies it to the joints and connective tissues of the body. It is a common misconception that the joints should not be “stressed”—that they should be “protected” during exercise. In fact, in the 1960s, yoga was sometimes declared as unfit for Westerners to do. In the next article, we will examine some of these misconceptions and determine the proper way to increase joint health—and how our teaching can facilitate it.

In the summer of 1979 Paul Grilley was inspired to study yoga after reading
Autobiography of a Yogi by Paramahansa Yogananda. After two years study of
anatomy with Dr. Garry Parker, he relocated from his home in Columbia Falls,
Montana to Los Angeles to continue his studies at UCLA. During his thirteen
years as a yoga teacher in Los Angeles, Paul studied Taoist yoga with
martial arts champion Paulie Zink. Since 1990 he has studied Yoga and
science with Dr. Hiroshi Motoyama. In 1998-2000 Paul relocated to Santa Fe
where he earned a Master’s Degree from St. John’s College. He currently
teaches yoga and anatomy worldwide and lives in Ashland, Oregon with his
wife Suzee. You can purchase his DVD Anatomy for Yoga at